Parallel fifths in the orchestraParallel Fifth in a Symphony OrchestralOrchestra warmup soundsHow important is harmony theory?Are there any “etudes for the orchestra”?How can a cello soloist practice projecting over orchestra?Score for orchestra tuningOrchestra notation and harmonyHow difficult is the orchestra part of Rachmaninoff's 3rd piano concerto?Do composers take advantage of the position of players in an orchestra for effect?Causes of the problems with hearing the singers over an orchestraPrepared myself for symphonic writing, still very nervous

Drums and punctuation

How to cut a climbing rope?

Security vulnerabilities of POST over SSL

Why are Stein manifolds/spaces the analog of affine varieties/schemes in algebraic geometry?

How did NASA Langley end up with the first 737?

Must a warlock replace spells with new spells of exactly their Pact Magic spell slot level?

The art of clickbait captions

Why are GND pads often only connected by four traces?

Why did Drogon spare this character?

How to patch glass cuts in a bicycle tire?

Why A=2 and B=1 in the call signs for Spirit and Opportunity?

Manager questioning my time estimates for a project

Can a person survive on blood in place of water?

Why does the hash of infinity have the digits of π?

On San Andreas Speedruns, why do players blow up the Picador in the mission Ryder?

How can I tell if I'm being too picky as a referee?

Gravitational Force Between Numbers

What does kpsewhich stand for?

Is it truly impossible to tell what a CPU is doing?

Is there a simple example that empirical evidence is misleading?

What are Antecedent & Consequent Phrases in Music?

Why does Bran want to find Drogon?

Need to read my home electrical Meter

How do I get the ς (final sigma) symbol?



Parallel fifths in the orchestra


Parallel Fifth in a Symphony OrchestralOrchestra warmup soundsHow important is harmony theory?Are there any “etudes for the orchestra”?How can a cello soloist practice projecting over orchestra?Score for orchestra tuningOrchestra notation and harmonyHow difficult is the orchestra part of Rachmaninoff's 3rd piano concerto?Do composers take advantage of the position of players in an orchestra for effect?Causes of the problems with hearing the singers over an orchestraPrepared myself for symphonic writing, still very nervous













4















I started to learn orchestral music with four part harmony for choirs and there you always try to avoid parallel fifths and octaves...
How does this relate to a whole orchestra? Do you have to take care of them only within the sections (strings, brass, woodwinds), do you have to take care of them within the whole orchestra or does it even matter in the whole orchestra?










share|improve this question







New contributor



Stone is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.














  • 1





    Imagine Violoncello and Doublebass: the will play octava parallels in any style. So don't mind the parallel fifths in orchestra voicing. It's not a question of "take care" it's a question of counterpoint and opposite motion. If you want it or if you need it ... do what you must do.

    – Albrecht Hügli
    5 hours ago











  • @AlbrechtHügli That’s not parallel octaves, that’s just doubling at the octave. Parallel octaves and fifths refer to the relationship between two entirely different voices, not just multiple lines playing the same voice.

    – Pat Muchmore
    1 hour ago















4















I started to learn orchestral music with four part harmony for choirs and there you always try to avoid parallel fifths and octaves...
How does this relate to a whole orchestra? Do you have to take care of them only within the sections (strings, brass, woodwinds), do you have to take care of them within the whole orchestra or does it even matter in the whole orchestra?










share|improve this question







New contributor



Stone is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.














  • 1





    Imagine Violoncello and Doublebass: the will play octava parallels in any style. So don't mind the parallel fifths in orchestra voicing. It's not a question of "take care" it's a question of counterpoint and opposite motion. If you want it or if you need it ... do what you must do.

    – Albrecht Hügli
    5 hours ago











  • @AlbrechtHügli That’s not parallel octaves, that’s just doubling at the octave. Parallel octaves and fifths refer to the relationship between two entirely different voices, not just multiple lines playing the same voice.

    – Pat Muchmore
    1 hour ago













4












4








4








I started to learn orchestral music with four part harmony for choirs and there you always try to avoid parallel fifths and octaves...
How does this relate to a whole orchestra? Do you have to take care of them only within the sections (strings, brass, woodwinds), do you have to take care of them within the whole orchestra or does it even matter in the whole orchestra?










share|improve this question







New contributor



Stone is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.











I started to learn orchestral music with four part harmony for choirs and there you always try to avoid parallel fifths and octaves...
How does this relate to a whole orchestra? Do you have to take care of them only within the sections (strings, brass, woodwinds), do you have to take care of them within the whole orchestra or does it even matter in the whole orchestra?







orchestra






share|improve this question







New contributor



Stone is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.










share|improve this question







New contributor



Stone is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.








share|improve this question




share|improve this question






New contributor



Stone is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.








asked 9 hours ago









StoneStone

295




295




New contributor



Stone is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.




New contributor




Stone is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.









  • 1





    Imagine Violoncello and Doublebass: the will play octava parallels in any style. So don't mind the parallel fifths in orchestra voicing. It's not a question of "take care" it's a question of counterpoint and opposite motion. If you want it or if you need it ... do what you must do.

    – Albrecht Hügli
    5 hours ago











  • @AlbrechtHügli That’s not parallel octaves, that’s just doubling at the octave. Parallel octaves and fifths refer to the relationship between two entirely different voices, not just multiple lines playing the same voice.

    – Pat Muchmore
    1 hour ago












  • 1





    Imagine Violoncello and Doublebass: the will play octava parallels in any style. So don't mind the parallel fifths in orchestra voicing. It's not a question of "take care" it's a question of counterpoint and opposite motion. If you want it or if you need it ... do what you must do.

    – Albrecht Hügli
    5 hours ago











  • @AlbrechtHügli That’s not parallel octaves, that’s just doubling at the octave. Parallel octaves and fifths refer to the relationship between two entirely different voices, not just multiple lines playing the same voice.

    – Pat Muchmore
    1 hour ago







1




1





Imagine Violoncello and Doublebass: the will play octava parallels in any style. So don't mind the parallel fifths in orchestra voicing. It's not a question of "take care" it's a question of counterpoint and opposite motion. If you want it or if you need it ... do what you must do.

– Albrecht Hügli
5 hours ago





Imagine Violoncello and Doublebass: the will play octava parallels in any style. So don't mind the parallel fifths in orchestra voicing. It's not a question of "take care" it's a question of counterpoint and opposite motion. If you want it or if you need it ... do what you must do.

– Albrecht Hügli
5 hours ago













@AlbrechtHügli That’s not parallel octaves, that’s just doubling at the octave. Parallel octaves and fifths refer to the relationship between two entirely different voices, not just multiple lines playing the same voice.

– Pat Muchmore
1 hour ago





@AlbrechtHügli That’s not parallel octaves, that’s just doubling at the octave. Parallel octaves and fifths refer to the relationship between two entirely different voices, not just multiple lines playing the same voice.

– Pat Muchmore
1 hour ago










4 Answers
4






active

oldest

votes


















7














IF you care about avoiding parallel fifths and octaves—and that’s entirely a stylistic choice on the part of the composer—then, for the most part, you care about them regardless of the instruments involved. And you care about them at the level of basic harmonic structure completely independent of the orchestration of the moment. In other words: no, it isn’t something you avoid only within a particular instrument family, it’s orchestra-wide.



For the European composers of common-practice tonal music in the 18th century (with considerable overlap into the 17th and 19th centuries as well), they almost always avoided these parallels, and they did so regardless of whether it was a piano sonata, or a symphony or anything in between. It’s a fundamental aspect of harmonic connection for them, not a surface level concern. What I mean is: by the time they’re thinking about how to distribute the harmonies amongst the instruments, the voice leading is already set. It’s not even something a composer of that period had to consciously think about, it’s just how the primary musical grammar worked for them. When they did want the sound of parallel fifths—as Beethoven did in a famous passage of the sixth symphony—they wrote it, but it wasn’t the default.



Here in the 21st century, most of us don’t already have this preconceived idea about how harmonies “should” connect. A lot of popular music styles use parallels all the time; in a lot of basic heavy metal music I would (only half-facetiously) say a composer was making a mistake if they didn’t use parallel fifths and octaves. Different musics have different grammars, but those grammars tend to apply regardless of specific instrumentation.






share|improve this answer






























    4














    There is a similar question to this one here: Parallel Fifth in a Symphony Orchestral



    However, I wouldn't say that it matters too much within the whole orchestra. People these days are so familiar with the sound from all the pop & rock songs out there. I think it will just fly by within a whole orchestral score with so many instruments playing at the same time.



    If you compose something and then think "ohh boy, this sounds like block-chords", then you probably should change it, but otherwise - if it sounds good to you, it sounds good to other people as well.



    You probably should only take care of them in small arrangements when they're exposed, but even then... There are no rules in music. If you like the sound, then stick with it.






    share|improve this answer






























      4














      Parallel 5ths are absolutely fine in choral music. In fact, the very earliest choral music was ALL parallel 5ths! Where they AREN'T fine is in a style of writing which values the effect of four independent voices, the style epitomised by Bach's chorale settings. Listen to the beautiful rich harmony of those, also listen to the barer but still beautiful effect in this piece.








      Both styles are perfectly valid in orchestral writing.






      share|improve this answer






























        1














        Two instruments which play parallel fifths or octaves will often sound like a single more powerful instrument. The extent to which this occurs will generally depend on the particular instruments involved. This effect can be very useful if employed in places where it would make musical sense. It can also be jarring if it occurs willy-nilly without rhyme or reason.



        Note that in a symphony orchestra, the number of different instruments will typically be much greater than the number of different musical lines that be maintained simultaneously. The most useful way to employ a symphony orchestra will thus often be to have various groups of instruments play various sections of music in parallel octaves or, less commonly, fifths, so that they sound--for those sections of music--like unified more powerful instruments. Note that when using parallel fifths, the part that's up a fifth should generally played on an instrument with a relatively "pure" tone, such as a flute.






        share|improve this answer























        • But that isn’t parallel motion (well not in the sense being used when talking about counterpoint) that’s just doubling. Doubling a voice in multiple octaves happens all the time even in solo piano music of the common-practice era; it’s only at the level of the fundamental voices that it’s generally avoided.

          – Pat Muchmore
          1 hour ago











        • @PatMuchmore If the doubling only happens sometimes, then it's still parallel. And you really need to make an Answer about this, because there's no reason to assume the OP makes such distinctions.

          – trlkly
          1 hour ago











        • @trlkly Yes, there is a point at which the distinction can become quite nuanced, you’re right. Separate lines coalesce into a single voice temporarily, and then separate later, and it isn’t always easy to make a distinction between legitimate doubling and un-stylistic voice leading. At any rate, I did write an answer, and tried to address the central confusion of the OP’s post, maybe I failed.

          – Pat Muchmore
          1 hour ago











        Your Answer








        StackExchange.ready(function()
        var channelOptions =
        tags: "".split(" "),
        id: "240"
        ;
        initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

        StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
        // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
        if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
        StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
        createEditor();
        );

        else
        createEditor();

        );

        function createEditor()
        StackExchange.prepareEditor(
        heartbeatType: 'answer',
        autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
        convertImagesToLinks: false,
        noModals: true,
        showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
        reputationToPostImages: null,
        bindNavPrevention: true,
        postfix: "",
        imageUploader:
        brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
        contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
        allowUrls: true
        ,
        noCode: true, onDemand: true,
        discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
        ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
        );



        );






        Stone is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.









        draft saved

        draft discarded


















        StackExchange.ready(
        function ()
        StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmusic.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f85104%2fparallel-fifths-in-the-orchestra%23new-answer', 'question_page');

        );

        Post as a guest















        Required, but never shown

























        4 Answers
        4






        active

        oldest

        votes








        4 Answers
        4






        active

        oldest

        votes









        active

        oldest

        votes






        active

        oldest

        votes









        7














        IF you care about avoiding parallel fifths and octaves—and that’s entirely a stylistic choice on the part of the composer—then, for the most part, you care about them regardless of the instruments involved. And you care about them at the level of basic harmonic structure completely independent of the orchestration of the moment. In other words: no, it isn’t something you avoid only within a particular instrument family, it’s orchestra-wide.



        For the European composers of common-practice tonal music in the 18th century (with considerable overlap into the 17th and 19th centuries as well), they almost always avoided these parallels, and they did so regardless of whether it was a piano sonata, or a symphony or anything in between. It’s a fundamental aspect of harmonic connection for them, not a surface level concern. What I mean is: by the time they’re thinking about how to distribute the harmonies amongst the instruments, the voice leading is already set. It’s not even something a composer of that period had to consciously think about, it’s just how the primary musical grammar worked for them. When they did want the sound of parallel fifths—as Beethoven did in a famous passage of the sixth symphony—they wrote it, but it wasn’t the default.



        Here in the 21st century, most of us don’t already have this preconceived idea about how harmonies “should” connect. A lot of popular music styles use parallels all the time; in a lot of basic heavy metal music I would (only half-facetiously) say a composer was making a mistake if they didn’t use parallel fifths and octaves. Different musics have different grammars, but those grammars tend to apply regardless of specific instrumentation.






        share|improve this answer



























          7














          IF you care about avoiding parallel fifths and octaves—and that’s entirely a stylistic choice on the part of the composer—then, for the most part, you care about them regardless of the instruments involved. And you care about them at the level of basic harmonic structure completely independent of the orchestration of the moment. In other words: no, it isn’t something you avoid only within a particular instrument family, it’s orchestra-wide.



          For the European composers of common-practice tonal music in the 18th century (with considerable overlap into the 17th and 19th centuries as well), they almost always avoided these parallels, and they did so regardless of whether it was a piano sonata, or a symphony or anything in between. It’s a fundamental aspect of harmonic connection for them, not a surface level concern. What I mean is: by the time they’re thinking about how to distribute the harmonies amongst the instruments, the voice leading is already set. It’s not even something a composer of that period had to consciously think about, it’s just how the primary musical grammar worked for them. When they did want the sound of parallel fifths—as Beethoven did in a famous passage of the sixth symphony—they wrote it, but it wasn’t the default.



          Here in the 21st century, most of us don’t already have this preconceived idea about how harmonies “should” connect. A lot of popular music styles use parallels all the time; in a lot of basic heavy metal music I would (only half-facetiously) say a composer was making a mistake if they didn’t use parallel fifths and octaves. Different musics have different grammars, but those grammars tend to apply regardless of specific instrumentation.






          share|improve this answer

























            7












            7








            7







            IF you care about avoiding parallel fifths and octaves—and that’s entirely a stylistic choice on the part of the composer—then, for the most part, you care about them regardless of the instruments involved. And you care about them at the level of basic harmonic structure completely independent of the orchestration of the moment. In other words: no, it isn’t something you avoid only within a particular instrument family, it’s orchestra-wide.



            For the European composers of common-practice tonal music in the 18th century (with considerable overlap into the 17th and 19th centuries as well), they almost always avoided these parallels, and they did so regardless of whether it was a piano sonata, or a symphony or anything in between. It’s a fundamental aspect of harmonic connection for them, not a surface level concern. What I mean is: by the time they’re thinking about how to distribute the harmonies amongst the instruments, the voice leading is already set. It’s not even something a composer of that period had to consciously think about, it’s just how the primary musical grammar worked for them. When they did want the sound of parallel fifths—as Beethoven did in a famous passage of the sixth symphony—they wrote it, but it wasn’t the default.



            Here in the 21st century, most of us don’t already have this preconceived idea about how harmonies “should” connect. A lot of popular music styles use parallels all the time; in a lot of basic heavy metal music I would (only half-facetiously) say a composer was making a mistake if they didn’t use parallel fifths and octaves. Different musics have different grammars, but those grammars tend to apply regardless of specific instrumentation.






            share|improve this answer













            IF you care about avoiding parallel fifths and octaves—and that’s entirely a stylistic choice on the part of the composer—then, for the most part, you care about them regardless of the instruments involved. And you care about them at the level of basic harmonic structure completely independent of the orchestration of the moment. In other words: no, it isn’t something you avoid only within a particular instrument family, it’s orchestra-wide.



            For the European composers of common-practice tonal music in the 18th century (with considerable overlap into the 17th and 19th centuries as well), they almost always avoided these parallels, and they did so regardless of whether it was a piano sonata, or a symphony or anything in between. It’s a fundamental aspect of harmonic connection for them, not a surface level concern. What I mean is: by the time they’re thinking about how to distribute the harmonies amongst the instruments, the voice leading is already set. It’s not even something a composer of that period had to consciously think about, it’s just how the primary musical grammar worked for them. When they did want the sound of parallel fifths—as Beethoven did in a famous passage of the sixth symphony—they wrote it, but it wasn’t the default.



            Here in the 21st century, most of us don’t already have this preconceived idea about how harmonies “should” connect. A lot of popular music styles use parallels all the time; in a lot of basic heavy metal music I would (only half-facetiously) say a composer was making a mistake if they didn’t use parallel fifths and octaves. Different musics have different grammars, but those grammars tend to apply regardless of specific instrumentation.







            share|improve this answer












            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer










            answered 8 hours ago









            Pat MuchmorePat Muchmore

            15.4k13276




            15.4k13276





















                4














                There is a similar question to this one here: Parallel Fifth in a Symphony Orchestral



                However, I wouldn't say that it matters too much within the whole orchestra. People these days are so familiar with the sound from all the pop & rock songs out there. I think it will just fly by within a whole orchestral score with so many instruments playing at the same time.



                If you compose something and then think "ohh boy, this sounds like block-chords", then you probably should change it, but otherwise - if it sounds good to you, it sounds good to other people as well.



                You probably should only take care of them in small arrangements when they're exposed, but even then... There are no rules in music. If you like the sound, then stick with it.






                share|improve this answer



























                  4














                  There is a similar question to this one here: Parallel Fifth in a Symphony Orchestral



                  However, I wouldn't say that it matters too much within the whole orchestra. People these days are so familiar with the sound from all the pop & rock songs out there. I think it will just fly by within a whole orchestral score with so many instruments playing at the same time.



                  If you compose something and then think "ohh boy, this sounds like block-chords", then you probably should change it, but otherwise - if it sounds good to you, it sounds good to other people as well.



                  You probably should only take care of them in small arrangements when they're exposed, but even then... There are no rules in music. If you like the sound, then stick with it.






                  share|improve this answer

























                    4












                    4








                    4







                    There is a similar question to this one here: Parallel Fifth in a Symphony Orchestral



                    However, I wouldn't say that it matters too much within the whole orchestra. People these days are so familiar with the sound from all the pop & rock songs out there. I think it will just fly by within a whole orchestral score with so many instruments playing at the same time.



                    If you compose something and then think "ohh boy, this sounds like block-chords", then you probably should change it, but otherwise - if it sounds good to you, it sounds good to other people as well.



                    You probably should only take care of them in small arrangements when they're exposed, but even then... There are no rules in music. If you like the sound, then stick with it.






                    share|improve this answer













                    There is a similar question to this one here: Parallel Fifth in a Symphony Orchestral



                    However, I wouldn't say that it matters too much within the whole orchestra. People these days are so familiar with the sound from all the pop & rock songs out there. I think it will just fly by within a whole orchestral score with so many instruments playing at the same time.



                    If you compose something and then think "ohh boy, this sounds like block-chords", then you probably should change it, but otherwise - if it sounds good to you, it sounds good to other people as well.



                    You probably should only take care of them in small arrangements when they're exposed, but even then... There are no rules in music. If you like the sound, then stick with it.







                    share|improve this answer












                    share|improve this answer



                    share|improve this answer










                    answered 9 hours ago









                    AndyAndy

                    55511




                    55511





















                        4














                        Parallel 5ths are absolutely fine in choral music. In fact, the very earliest choral music was ALL parallel 5ths! Where they AREN'T fine is in a style of writing which values the effect of four independent voices, the style epitomised by Bach's chorale settings. Listen to the beautiful rich harmony of those, also listen to the barer but still beautiful effect in this piece.








                        Both styles are perfectly valid in orchestral writing.






                        share|improve this answer



























                          4














                          Parallel 5ths are absolutely fine in choral music. In fact, the very earliest choral music was ALL parallel 5ths! Where they AREN'T fine is in a style of writing which values the effect of four independent voices, the style epitomised by Bach's chorale settings. Listen to the beautiful rich harmony of those, also listen to the barer but still beautiful effect in this piece.








                          Both styles are perfectly valid in orchestral writing.






                          share|improve this answer

























                            4












                            4








                            4







                            Parallel 5ths are absolutely fine in choral music. In fact, the very earliest choral music was ALL parallel 5ths! Where they AREN'T fine is in a style of writing which values the effect of four independent voices, the style epitomised by Bach's chorale settings. Listen to the beautiful rich harmony of those, also listen to the barer but still beautiful effect in this piece.








                            Both styles are perfectly valid in orchestral writing.






                            share|improve this answer













                            Parallel 5ths are absolutely fine in choral music. In fact, the very earliest choral music was ALL parallel 5ths! Where they AREN'T fine is in a style of writing which values the effect of four independent voices, the style epitomised by Bach's chorale settings. Listen to the beautiful rich harmony of those, also listen to the barer but still beautiful effect in this piece.








                            Both styles are perfectly valid in orchestral writing.















                            share|improve this answer












                            share|improve this answer



                            share|improve this answer










                            answered 9 hours ago









                            Laurence PayneLaurence Payne

                            39.2k2074




                            39.2k2074





















                                1














                                Two instruments which play parallel fifths or octaves will often sound like a single more powerful instrument. The extent to which this occurs will generally depend on the particular instruments involved. This effect can be very useful if employed in places where it would make musical sense. It can also be jarring if it occurs willy-nilly without rhyme or reason.



                                Note that in a symphony orchestra, the number of different instruments will typically be much greater than the number of different musical lines that be maintained simultaneously. The most useful way to employ a symphony orchestra will thus often be to have various groups of instruments play various sections of music in parallel octaves or, less commonly, fifths, so that they sound--for those sections of music--like unified more powerful instruments. Note that when using parallel fifths, the part that's up a fifth should generally played on an instrument with a relatively "pure" tone, such as a flute.






                                share|improve this answer























                                • But that isn’t parallel motion (well not in the sense being used when talking about counterpoint) that’s just doubling. Doubling a voice in multiple octaves happens all the time even in solo piano music of the common-practice era; it’s only at the level of the fundamental voices that it’s generally avoided.

                                  – Pat Muchmore
                                  1 hour ago











                                • @PatMuchmore If the doubling only happens sometimes, then it's still parallel. And you really need to make an Answer about this, because there's no reason to assume the OP makes such distinctions.

                                  – trlkly
                                  1 hour ago











                                • @trlkly Yes, there is a point at which the distinction can become quite nuanced, you’re right. Separate lines coalesce into a single voice temporarily, and then separate later, and it isn’t always easy to make a distinction between legitimate doubling and un-stylistic voice leading. At any rate, I did write an answer, and tried to address the central confusion of the OP’s post, maybe I failed.

                                  – Pat Muchmore
                                  1 hour ago















                                1














                                Two instruments which play parallel fifths or octaves will often sound like a single more powerful instrument. The extent to which this occurs will generally depend on the particular instruments involved. This effect can be very useful if employed in places where it would make musical sense. It can also be jarring if it occurs willy-nilly without rhyme or reason.



                                Note that in a symphony orchestra, the number of different instruments will typically be much greater than the number of different musical lines that be maintained simultaneously. The most useful way to employ a symphony orchestra will thus often be to have various groups of instruments play various sections of music in parallel octaves or, less commonly, fifths, so that they sound--for those sections of music--like unified more powerful instruments. Note that when using parallel fifths, the part that's up a fifth should generally played on an instrument with a relatively "pure" tone, such as a flute.






                                share|improve this answer























                                • But that isn’t parallel motion (well not in the sense being used when talking about counterpoint) that’s just doubling. Doubling a voice in multiple octaves happens all the time even in solo piano music of the common-practice era; it’s only at the level of the fundamental voices that it’s generally avoided.

                                  – Pat Muchmore
                                  1 hour ago











                                • @PatMuchmore If the doubling only happens sometimes, then it's still parallel. And you really need to make an Answer about this, because there's no reason to assume the OP makes such distinctions.

                                  – trlkly
                                  1 hour ago











                                • @trlkly Yes, there is a point at which the distinction can become quite nuanced, you’re right. Separate lines coalesce into a single voice temporarily, and then separate later, and it isn’t always easy to make a distinction between legitimate doubling and un-stylistic voice leading. At any rate, I did write an answer, and tried to address the central confusion of the OP’s post, maybe I failed.

                                  – Pat Muchmore
                                  1 hour ago













                                1












                                1








                                1







                                Two instruments which play parallel fifths or octaves will often sound like a single more powerful instrument. The extent to which this occurs will generally depend on the particular instruments involved. This effect can be very useful if employed in places where it would make musical sense. It can also be jarring if it occurs willy-nilly without rhyme or reason.



                                Note that in a symphony orchestra, the number of different instruments will typically be much greater than the number of different musical lines that be maintained simultaneously. The most useful way to employ a symphony orchestra will thus often be to have various groups of instruments play various sections of music in parallel octaves or, less commonly, fifths, so that they sound--for those sections of music--like unified more powerful instruments. Note that when using parallel fifths, the part that's up a fifth should generally played on an instrument with a relatively "pure" tone, such as a flute.






                                share|improve this answer













                                Two instruments which play parallel fifths or octaves will often sound like a single more powerful instrument. The extent to which this occurs will generally depend on the particular instruments involved. This effect can be very useful if employed in places where it would make musical sense. It can also be jarring if it occurs willy-nilly without rhyme or reason.



                                Note that in a symphony orchestra, the number of different instruments will typically be much greater than the number of different musical lines that be maintained simultaneously. The most useful way to employ a symphony orchestra will thus often be to have various groups of instruments play various sections of music in parallel octaves or, less commonly, fifths, so that they sound--for those sections of music--like unified more powerful instruments. Note that when using parallel fifths, the part that's up a fifth should generally played on an instrument with a relatively "pure" tone, such as a flute.







                                share|improve this answer












                                share|improve this answer



                                share|improve this answer










                                answered 4 hours ago









                                supercatsupercat

                                2,4901015




                                2,4901015












                                • But that isn’t parallel motion (well not in the sense being used when talking about counterpoint) that’s just doubling. Doubling a voice in multiple octaves happens all the time even in solo piano music of the common-practice era; it’s only at the level of the fundamental voices that it’s generally avoided.

                                  – Pat Muchmore
                                  1 hour ago











                                • @PatMuchmore If the doubling only happens sometimes, then it's still parallel. And you really need to make an Answer about this, because there's no reason to assume the OP makes such distinctions.

                                  – trlkly
                                  1 hour ago











                                • @trlkly Yes, there is a point at which the distinction can become quite nuanced, you’re right. Separate lines coalesce into a single voice temporarily, and then separate later, and it isn’t always easy to make a distinction between legitimate doubling and un-stylistic voice leading. At any rate, I did write an answer, and tried to address the central confusion of the OP’s post, maybe I failed.

                                  – Pat Muchmore
                                  1 hour ago

















                                • But that isn’t parallel motion (well not in the sense being used when talking about counterpoint) that’s just doubling. Doubling a voice in multiple octaves happens all the time even in solo piano music of the common-practice era; it’s only at the level of the fundamental voices that it’s generally avoided.

                                  – Pat Muchmore
                                  1 hour ago











                                • @PatMuchmore If the doubling only happens sometimes, then it's still parallel. And you really need to make an Answer about this, because there's no reason to assume the OP makes such distinctions.

                                  – trlkly
                                  1 hour ago











                                • @trlkly Yes, there is a point at which the distinction can become quite nuanced, you’re right. Separate lines coalesce into a single voice temporarily, and then separate later, and it isn’t always easy to make a distinction between legitimate doubling and un-stylistic voice leading. At any rate, I did write an answer, and tried to address the central confusion of the OP’s post, maybe I failed.

                                  – Pat Muchmore
                                  1 hour ago
















                                But that isn’t parallel motion (well not in the sense being used when talking about counterpoint) that’s just doubling. Doubling a voice in multiple octaves happens all the time even in solo piano music of the common-practice era; it’s only at the level of the fundamental voices that it’s generally avoided.

                                – Pat Muchmore
                                1 hour ago





                                But that isn’t parallel motion (well not in the sense being used when talking about counterpoint) that’s just doubling. Doubling a voice in multiple octaves happens all the time even in solo piano music of the common-practice era; it’s only at the level of the fundamental voices that it’s generally avoided.

                                – Pat Muchmore
                                1 hour ago













                                @PatMuchmore If the doubling only happens sometimes, then it's still parallel. And you really need to make an Answer about this, because there's no reason to assume the OP makes such distinctions.

                                – trlkly
                                1 hour ago





                                @PatMuchmore If the doubling only happens sometimes, then it's still parallel. And you really need to make an Answer about this, because there's no reason to assume the OP makes such distinctions.

                                – trlkly
                                1 hour ago













                                @trlkly Yes, there is a point at which the distinction can become quite nuanced, you’re right. Separate lines coalesce into a single voice temporarily, and then separate later, and it isn’t always easy to make a distinction between legitimate doubling and un-stylistic voice leading. At any rate, I did write an answer, and tried to address the central confusion of the OP’s post, maybe I failed.

                                – Pat Muchmore
                                1 hour ago





                                @trlkly Yes, there is a point at which the distinction can become quite nuanced, you’re right. Separate lines coalesce into a single voice temporarily, and then separate later, and it isn’t always easy to make a distinction between legitimate doubling and un-stylistic voice leading. At any rate, I did write an answer, and tried to address the central confusion of the OP’s post, maybe I failed.

                                – Pat Muchmore
                                1 hour ago










                                Stone is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.









                                draft saved

                                draft discarded


















                                Stone is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.












                                Stone is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.











                                Stone is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.














                                Thanks for contributing an answer to Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange!


                                • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

                                But avoid


                                • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

                                • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

                                To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




                                draft saved


                                draft discarded














                                StackExchange.ready(
                                function ()
                                StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmusic.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f85104%2fparallel-fifths-in-the-orchestra%23new-answer', 'question_page');

                                );

                                Post as a guest















                                Required, but never shown





















































                                Required, but never shown














                                Required, but never shown












                                Required, but never shown







                                Required, but never shown

































                                Required, but never shown














                                Required, but never shown












                                Required, but never shown







                                Required, but never shown







                                Popular posts from this blog

                                19. јануар Садржај Догађаји Рођења Смрти Празници и дани сећања Види још Референце Мени за навигацијуу

                                Israel Cuprins Etimologie | Istorie | Geografie | Politică | Demografie | Educație | Economie | Cultură | Note explicative | Note bibliografice | Bibliografie | Legături externe | Meniu de navigaresite web oficialfacebooktweeterGoogle+Instagramcanal YouTubeInstagramtextmodificaremodificarewww.technion.ac.ilnew.huji.ac.ilwww.weizmann.ac.ilwww1.biu.ac.ilenglish.tau.ac.ilwww.haifa.ac.ilin.bgu.ac.ilwww.openu.ac.ilwww.ariel.ac.ilCIA FactbookHarta Israelului"Negotiating Jerusalem," Palestine–Israel JournalThe Schizoid Nature of Modern Hebrew: A Slavic Language in Search of a Semitic Past„Arabic in Israel: an official language and a cultural bridge”„Latest Population Statistics for Israel”„Israel Population”„Tables”„Report for Selected Countries and Subjects”Human Development Report 2016: Human Development for Everyone„Distribution of family income - Gini index”The World FactbookJerusalem Law„Israel”„Israel”„Zionist Leaders: David Ben-Gurion 1886–1973”„The status of Jerusalem”„Analysis: Kadima's big plans”„Israel's Hard-Learned Lessons”„The Legacy of Undefined Borders, Tel Aviv Notes No. 40, 5 iunie 2002”„Israel Journal: A Land Without Borders”„Population”„Israel closes decade with population of 7.5 million”Time Series-DataBank„Selected Statistics on Jerusalem Day 2007 (Hebrew)”Golan belongs to Syria, Druze protestGlobal Survey 2006: Middle East Progress Amid Global Gains in FreedomWHO: Life expectancy in Israel among highest in the worldInternational Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook Database, April 2011: Nominal GDP list of countries. Data for the year 2010.„Israel's accession to the OECD”Popular Opinion„On the Move”Hosea 12:5„Walking the Bible Timeline”„Palestine: History”„Return to Zion”An invention called 'the Jewish people' – Haaretz – Israel NewsoriginalJewish and Non-Jewish Population of Palestine-Israel (1517–2004)ImmigrationJewishvirtuallibrary.orgChapter One: The Heralders of Zionism„The birth of modern Israel: A scrap of paper that changed history”„League of Nations: The Mandate for Palestine, 24 iulie 1922”The Population of Palestine Prior to 1948originalBackground Paper No. 47 (ST/DPI/SER.A/47)History: Foreign DominationTwo Hundred and Seventh Plenary Meeting„Israel (Labor Zionism)”Population, by Religion and Population GroupThe Suez CrisisAdolf EichmannJustice Ministry Reply to Amnesty International Report„The Interregnum”Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs – The Palestinian National Covenant- July 1968Research on terrorism: trends, achievements & failuresThe Routledge Atlas of the Arab–Israeli conflict: The Complete History of the Struggle and the Efforts to Resolve It"George Habash, Palestinian Terrorism Tactician, Dies at 82."„1973: Arab states attack Israeli forces”Agranat Commission„Has Israel Annexed East Jerusalem?”original„After 4 Years, Intifada Still Smolders”From the End of the Cold War to 2001originalThe Oslo Accords, 1993Israel-PLO Recognition – Exchange of Letters between PM Rabin and Chairman Arafat – Sept 9- 1993Foundation for Middle East PeaceSources of Population Growth: Total Israeli Population and Settler Population, 1991–2003original„Israel marks Rabin assassination”The Wye River Memorandumoriginal„West Bank barrier route disputed, Israeli missile kills 2”"Permanent Ceasefire to Be Based on Creation Of Buffer Zone Free of Armed Personnel Other than UN, Lebanese Forces"„Hezbollah kills 8 soldiers, kidnaps two in offensive on northern border”„Olmert confirms peace talks with Syria”„Battleground Gaza: Israeli ground forces invade the strip”„IDF begins Gaza troop withdrawal, hours after ending 3-week offensive”„THE LAND: Geography and Climate”„Area of districts, sub-districts, natural regions and lakes”„Israel - Geography”„Makhteshim Country”Israel and the Palestinian Territories„Makhtesh Ramon”„The Living Dead Sea”„Temperatures reach record high in Pakistan”„Climate Extremes In Israel”Israel in figures„Deuteronom”„JNF: 240 million trees planted since 1901”„Vegetation of Israel and Neighboring Countries”Environmental Law in Israel„Executive branch”„Israel's election process explained”„The Electoral System in Israel”„Constitution for Israel”„All 120 incoming Knesset members”„Statul ISRAEL”„The Judiciary: The Court System”„Israel's high court unique in region”„Israel and the International Criminal Court: A Legal Battlefield”„Localities and population, by population group, district, sub-district and natural region”„Israel: Districts, Major Cities, Urban Localities & Metropolitan Areas”„Israel-Egypt Relations: Background & Overview of Peace Treaty”„Solana to Haaretz: New Rules of War Needed for Age of Terror”„Israel's Announcement Regarding Settlements”„United Nations Security Council Resolution 497”„Security Council resolution 478 (1980) on the status of Jerusalem”„Arabs will ask U.N. to seek razing of Israeli wall”„Olmert: Willing to trade land for peace”„Mapping Peace between Syria and Israel”„Egypt: Israel must accept the land-for-peace formula”„Israel: Age structure from 2005 to 2015”„Global, regional, and national disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) for 306 diseases and injuries and healthy life expectancy (HALE) for 188 countries, 1990–2013: quantifying the epidemiological transition”10.1016/S0140-6736(15)61340-X„World Health Statistics 2014”„Life expectancy for Israeli men world's 4th highest”„Family Structure and Well-Being Across Israel's Diverse Population”„Fertility among Jewish and Muslim Women in Israel, by Level of Religiosity, 1979-2009”„Israel leaders in birth rate, but poverty major challenge”„Ethnic Groups”„Israel's population: Over 8.5 million”„Israel - Ethnic groups”„Jews, by country of origin and age”„Minority Communities in Israel: Background & Overview”„Israel”„Language in Israel”„Selected Data from the 2011 Social Survey on Mastery of the Hebrew Language and Usage of Languages”„Religions”„5 facts about Israeli Druze, a unique religious and ethnic group”„Israël”Israel Country Study Guide„Haredi city in Negev – blessing or curse?”„New town Harish harbors hopes of being more than another Pleasantville”„List of localities, in alphabetical order”„Muncitorii români, doriți în Israel”„Prietenia româno-israeliană la nevoie se cunoaște”„The Higher Education System in Israel”„Middle East”„Academic Ranking of World Universities 2016”„Israel”„Israel”„Jewish Nobel Prize Winners”„All Nobel Prizes in Literature”„All Nobel Peace Prizes”„All Prizes in Economic Sciences”„All Nobel Prizes in Chemistry”„List of Fields Medallists”„Sakharov Prize”„Țara care și-a sfidat "destinul" și se bate umăr la umăr cu Silicon Valley”„Apple's R&D center in Israel grew to about 800 employees”„Tim Cook: Apple's Herzliya R&D center second-largest in world”„Lecții de economie de la Israel”„Land use”Israel Investment and Business GuideA Country Study: IsraelCentral Bureau of StatisticsFlorin Diaconu, „Kadima: Flexibilitate și pragmatism, dar nici un compromis în chestiuni vitale", în Revista Institutului Diplomatic Român, anul I, numărul I, semestrul I, 2006, pp. 71-72Florin Diaconu, „Likud: Dreapta israeliană constant opusă retrocedării teritoriilor cureite prin luptă în 1967", în Revista Institutului Diplomatic Român, anul I, numărul I, semestrul I, 2006, pp. 73-74MassadaIsraelul a crescut in 50 de ani cât alte state intr-un mileniuIsrael Government PortalIsraelIsraelIsraelmmmmmXX451232cb118646298(data)4027808-634110000 0004 0372 0767n7900328503691455-bb46-37e3-91d2-cb064a35ffcc1003570400564274ge1294033523775214929302638955X146498911146498911

                                Кастелфранко ди Сопра Становништво Референце Спољашње везе Мени за навигацију43°37′18″ СГШ; 11°33′32″ ИГД / 43.62156° СГШ; 11.55885° ИГД / 43.62156; 11.5588543°37′18″ СГШ; 11°33′32″ ИГД / 43.62156° СГШ; 11.55885° ИГД / 43.62156; 11.558853179688„The GeoNames geographical database”„Istituto Nazionale di Statistica”проширитиууWorldCat156923403n850174324558639-1cb14643287r(подаци)