Duplicate instruments in unison in an orchestraSpectrum of brass tones of same fingeringOrchestration and painting evenly over the spectrumExtended range electric basses versus extended range electric guitarsWhy are some/most B♭-clarinets tuned to A=442 Hz?Orchestration question: when can basses get muddy?Why are drums from high to low and other instruments from low to high?Designing the home audio setup with musical instruments in mindPitch and Volume Compensations for Different Instruments

Can a Rogue PC teach an NPC to perform Sneak Attack?

Where was Carl Sagan working on a plan to detonate a nuke on the Moon? Where was he applying when he leaked it?

Disambiguation of "nobis vobis" and "nobis nobis"

Could George I (of Great Britain) speak English?

Handling Disruptive Student on the Autistic Spectrum

Is there any way to keep a player from killing an NPC?

How do I prevent other wifi networks from showing up on my computer?

How to handle torpor?

How would a Creature that needs to be seen by Humans evolve?

How to determine car loan length as a function of how long I plan to keep a car

Lost property on Portuguese trains

How do I get toddlers to stop asking for food every hour?

What setting causes my autoindent to add indent on a new line?

I don't have the theoretical background in my PhD topic. I can't justify getting the degree

Why do banks “park” their money at the European Central Bank?

Why did Khan ask Admiral James T. Kirk about Project Genesis?

Can RMSE and MAE have the same value?

Nothing like a good ol' game of ModTen

Why in most German places is the church the tallest building?

What should come first--characters or plot?

Is "The life is beautiful" incorrect or just very non-idiomatic?

Why do all fields in a QFT transform like *irreducible* representations of some group?

How do we calculate energy of food?

Read file lines into shell line separated by space



Duplicate instruments in unison in an orchestra


Spectrum of brass tones of same fingeringOrchestration and painting evenly over the spectrumExtended range electric basses versus extended range electric guitarsWhy are some/most B♭-clarinets tuned to A=442 Hz?Orchestration question: when can basses get muddy?Why are drums from high to low and other instruments from low to high?Designing the home audio setup with musical instruments in mindPitch and Volume Compensations for Different Instruments






.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;








2















Theoretically, each addition of a sound identical to the previous one results in a 6db increase in the final sound result.



I ask: is that why in some orchestrations we see, for example, 6 clarinets playing the same passage in unison, that is, just to increase the final volume and highlight this passage beyond the other instruments?










share|improve this question
























  • So if I am listening to (e.g.) a trumpet and a second trumpet joins in playing the same thing then you say the volume increase is around 6dB, yes? I would have expected the volume to increase by around a factor of two, which I thought was about 10dB. Where am I going wrong? (Simple answers only please, my physics is lousy!)

    – JimM
    8 hours ago







  • 4





    No, you're misunderstanding the relationship between 'power', 'volume' & 'perception' See sengpielaudio.com/calculator-levelchange.htm which covers it better than I could here.

    – Tetsujin
    8 hours ago






  • 1





    @JimM 3 dB is a factor of two. 10dB is a factor of 100 -- just look up the definition of a decibel; and beware of the difference between amplitude and power.

    – Carl Witthoft
    7 hours ago

















2















Theoretically, each addition of a sound identical to the previous one results in a 6db increase in the final sound result.



I ask: is that why in some orchestrations we see, for example, 6 clarinets playing the same passage in unison, that is, just to increase the final volume and highlight this passage beyond the other instruments?










share|improve this question
























  • So if I am listening to (e.g.) a trumpet and a second trumpet joins in playing the same thing then you say the volume increase is around 6dB, yes? I would have expected the volume to increase by around a factor of two, which I thought was about 10dB. Where am I going wrong? (Simple answers only please, my physics is lousy!)

    – JimM
    8 hours ago







  • 4





    No, you're misunderstanding the relationship between 'power', 'volume' & 'perception' See sengpielaudio.com/calculator-levelchange.htm which covers it better than I could here.

    – Tetsujin
    8 hours ago






  • 1





    @JimM 3 dB is a factor of two. 10dB is a factor of 100 -- just look up the definition of a decibel; and beware of the difference between amplitude and power.

    – Carl Witthoft
    7 hours ago













2












2








2








Theoretically, each addition of a sound identical to the previous one results in a 6db increase in the final sound result.



I ask: is that why in some orchestrations we see, for example, 6 clarinets playing the same passage in unison, that is, just to increase the final volume and highlight this passage beyond the other instruments?










share|improve this question














Theoretically, each addition of a sound identical to the previous one results in a 6db increase in the final sound result.



I ask: is that why in some orchestrations we see, for example, 6 clarinets playing the same passage in unison, that is, just to increase the final volume and highlight this passage beyond the other instruments?







instruments audio orchestration






share|improve this question













share|improve this question











share|improve this question




share|improve this question










asked 9 hours ago









Rogério DecRogério Dec

2141 silver badge7 bronze badges




2141 silver badge7 bronze badges















  • So if I am listening to (e.g.) a trumpet and a second trumpet joins in playing the same thing then you say the volume increase is around 6dB, yes? I would have expected the volume to increase by around a factor of two, which I thought was about 10dB. Where am I going wrong? (Simple answers only please, my physics is lousy!)

    – JimM
    8 hours ago







  • 4





    No, you're misunderstanding the relationship between 'power', 'volume' & 'perception' See sengpielaudio.com/calculator-levelchange.htm which covers it better than I could here.

    – Tetsujin
    8 hours ago






  • 1





    @JimM 3 dB is a factor of two. 10dB is a factor of 100 -- just look up the definition of a decibel; and beware of the difference between amplitude and power.

    – Carl Witthoft
    7 hours ago

















  • So if I am listening to (e.g.) a trumpet and a second trumpet joins in playing the same thing then you say the volume increase is around 6dB, yes? I would have expected the volume to increase by around a factor of two, which I thought was about 10dB. Where am I going wrong? (Simple answers only please, my physics is lousy!)

    – JimM
    8 hours ago







  • 4





    No, you're misunderstanding the relationship between 'power', 'volume' & 'perception' See sengpielaudio.com/calculator-levelchange.htm which covers it better than I could here.

    – Tetsujin
    8 hours ago






  • 1





    @JimM 3 dB is a factor of two. 10dB is a factor of 100 -- just look up the definition of a decibel; and beware of the difference between amplitude and power.

    – Carl Witthoft
    7 hours ago
















So if I am listening to (e.g.) a trumpet and a second trumpet joins in playing the same thing then you say the volume increase is around 6dB, yes? I would have expected the volume to increase by around a factor of two, which I thought was about 10dB. Where am I going wrong? (Simple answers only please, my physics is lousy!)

– JimM
8 hours ago






So if I am listening to (e.g.) a trumpet and a second trumpet joins in playing the same thing then you say the volume increase is around 6dB, yes? I would have expected the volume to increase by around a factor of two, which I thought was about 10dB. Where am I going wrong? (Simple answers only please, my physics is lousy!)

– JimM
8 hours ago





4




4





No, you're misunderstanding the relationship between 'power', 'volume' & 'perception' See sengpielaudio.com/calculator-levelchange.htm which covers it better than I could here.

– Tetsujin
8 hours ago





No, you're misunderstanding the relationship between 'power', 'volume' & 'perception' See sengpielaudio.com/calculator-levelchange.htm which covers it better than I could here.

– Tetsujin
8 hours ago




1




1





@JimM 3 dB is a factor of two. 10dB is a factor of 100 -- just look up the definition of a decibel; and beware of the difference between amplitude and power.

– Carl Witthoft
7 hours ago





@JimM 3 dB is a factor of two. 10dB is a factor of 100 -- just look up the definition of a decibel; and beware of the difference between amplitude and power.

– Carl Witthoft
7 hours ago










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes


















3















Since the different instruments are not producing the exact same waveforms perfectly phase aligned, there is not nearly a 6 dB boost when the number of instruments playing the same part is doubled. It’s more complicated than that.



The doubling has two effects: first, there is a volume increase, and as some instruments are quieter than others, this can really help with the overall mix of the orchestra. It also helps with playing in bigger rooms. A modern version of this was that James Brown would have two drummers playing the same part so they could be loud enough without amplification. Or the drummers would take turns playing songs because they had to hit so hard they had to take breaks.



The second reason to double parts is to create a different timbre. A violin section playing in unison sounds very different from a single violin playing the same notes. And the size of the section makes a difference. Chamber strings sound “smaller” than symphonic strings.



I guess there’s a third reason which is if you want to create a note of arbitrary length, you can have a section sustain that note for a very long time assuming the players choose different times to breathe (which pros know to do without being asked). So the section sort of turns into a single instrument that has a different timbre and capabilities compared to a solo instrument.






share|improve this answer




















  • 1





    Especially in choral singing, where the difference between one voice and two is staggering, even when everyone's trying to blend. And also similarly to a choir, the staggered breathing through long notes was something I was taught in third grade in a school choir. Good answer.

    – user45266
    5 hours ago


















3















In brief, certainly one reason for multiple instruments in unison is to achieve greater total signal (sound) power output.



In detail,

1) Two instruments will not add coherently, so the power ratio is additive, i.e. 2 are roughly twice the power (in linear units), three produces 3X the (linear) power. If they were coherent, the peak power would be 2^(number of instruments), except where the off-axis interference produced nulls.

2) Because the instruments are never perfectly in tune, nor do they produce exactly the same overtone ratios, the sound of, e.g., a 10-instrument first violin section sounds very different from the highly amplified sound from one violin.

3) Even if the instruments were identical in output, the tone quality is a function of the amplitude -- a clarinet played fortissimo does not sound like 10 clarinets played pianissimo.






share|improve this answer



























    Your Answer








    StackExchange.ready(function()
    var channelOptions =
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "240"
    ;
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
    createEditor();
    );

    else
    createEditor();

    );

    function createEditor()
    StackExchange.prepareEditor(
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
    convertImagesToLinks: false,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: null,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader:
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    ,
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    );



    );













    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function ()
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmusic.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f88042%2fduplicate-instruments-in-unison-in-an-orchestra%23new-answer', 'question_page');

    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    3















    Since the different instruments are not producing the exact same waveforms perfectly phase aligned, there is not nearly a 6 dB boost when the number of instruments playing the same part is doubled. It’s more complicated than that.



    The doubling has two effects: first, there is a volume increase, and as some instruments are quieter than others, this can really help with the overall mix of the orchestra. It also helps with playing in bigger rooms. A modern version of this was that James Brown would have two drummers playing the same part so they could be loud enough without amplification. Or the drummers would take turns playing songs because they had to hit so hard they had to take breaks.



    The second reason to double parts is to create a different timbre. A violin section playing in unison sounds very different from a single violin playing the same notes. And the size of the section makes a difference. Chamber strings sound “smaller” than symphonic strings.



    I guess there’s a third reason which is if you want to create a note of arbitrary length, you can have a section sustain that note for a very long time assuming the players choose different times to breathe (which pros know to do without being asked). So the section sort of turns into a single instrument that has a different timbre and capabilities compared to a solo instrument.






    share|improve this answer




















    • 1





      Especially in choral singing, where the difference between one voice and two is staggering, even when everyone's trying to blend. And also similarly to a choir, the staggered breathing through long notes was something I was taught in third grade in a school choir. Good answer.

      – user45266
      5 hours ago















    3















    Since the different instruments are not producing the exact same waveforms perfectly phase aligned, there is not nearly a 6 dB boost when the number of instruments playing the same part is doubled. It’s more complicated than that.



    The doubling has two effects: first, there is a volume increase, and as some instruments are quieter than others, this can really help with the overall mix of the orchestra. It also helps with playing in bigger rooms. A modern version of this was that James Brown would have two drummers playing the same part so they could be loud enough without amplification. Or the drummers would take turns playing songs because they had to hit so hard they had to take breaks.



    The second reason to double parts is to create a different timbre. A violin section playing in unison sounds very different from a single violin playing the same notes. And the size of the section makes a difference. Chamber strings sound “smaller” than symphonic strings.



    I guess there’s a third reason which is if you want to create a note of arbitrary length, you can have a section sustain that note for a very long time assuming the players choose different times to breathe (which pros know to do without being asked). So the section sort of turns into a single instrument that has a different timbre and capabilities compared to a solo instrument.






    share|improve this answer




















    • 1





      Especially in choral singing, where the difference between one voice and two is staggering, even when everyone's trying to blend. And also similarly to a choir, the staggered breathing through long notes was something I was taught in third grade in a school choir. Good answer.

      – user45266
      5 hours ago













    3














    3










    3









    Since the different instruments are not producing the exact same waveforms perfectly phase aligned, there is not nearly a 6 dB boost when the number of instruments playing the same part is doubled. It’s more complicated than that.



    The doubling has two effects: first, there is a volume increase, and as some instruments are quieter than others, this can really help with the overall mix of the orchestra. It also helps with playing in bigger rooms. A modern version of this was that James Brown would have two drummers playing the same part so they could be loud enough without amplification. Or the drummers would take turns playing songs because they had to hit so hard they had to take breaks.



    The second reason to double parts is to create a different timbre. A violin section playing in unison sounds very different from a single violin playing the same notes. And the size of the section makes a difference. Chamber strings sound “smaller” than symphonic strings.



    I guess there’s a third reason which is if you want to create a note of arbitrary length, you can have a section sustain that note for a very long time assuming the players choose different times to breathe (which pros know to do without being asked). So the section sort of turns into a single instrument that has a different timbre and capabilities compared to a solo instrument.






    share|improve this answer













    Since the different instruments are not producing the exact same waveforms perfectly phase aligned, there is not nearly a 6 dB boost when the number of instruments playing the same part is doubled. It’s more complicated than that.



    The doubling has two effects: first, there is a volume increase, and as some instruments are quieter than others, this can really help with the overall mix of the orchestra. It also helps with playing in bigger rooms. A modern version of this was that James Brown would have two drummers playing the same part so they could be loud enough without amplification. Or the drummers would take turns playing songs because they had to hit so hard they had to take breaks.



    The second reason to double parts is to create a different timbre. A violin section playing in unison sounds very different from a single violin playing the same notes. And the size of the section makes a difference. Chamber strings sound “smaller” than symphonic strings.



    I guess there’s a third reason which is if you want to create a note of arbitrary length, you can have a section sustain that note for a very long time assuming the players choose different times to breathe (which pros know to do without being asked). So the section sort of turns into a single instrument that has a different timbre and capabilities compared to a solo instrument.







    share|improve this answer












    share|improve this answer



    share|improve this answer










    answered 7 hours ago









    Todd WilcoxTodd Wilcox

    40.5k4 gold badges76 silver badges137 bronze badges




    40.5k4 gold badges76 silver badges137 bronze badges










    • 1





      Especially in choral singing, where the difference between one voice and two is staggering, even when everyone's trying to blend. And also similarly to a choir, the staggered breathing through long notes was something I was taught in third grade in a school choir. Good answer.

      – user45266
      5 hours ago












    • 1





      Especially in choral singing, where the difference between one voice and two is staggering, even when everyone's trying to blend. And also similarly to a choir, the staggered breathing through long notes was something I was taught in third grade in a school choir. Good answer.

      – user45266
      5 hours ago







    1




    1





    Especially in choral singing, where the difference between one voice and two is staggering, even when everyone's trying to blend. And also similarly to a choir, the staggered breathing through long notes was something I was taught in third grade in a school choir. Good answer.

    – user45266
    5 hours ago





    Especially in choral singing, where the difference between one voice and two is staggering, even when everyone's trying to blend. And also similarly to a choir, the staggered breathing through long notes was something I was taught in third grade in a school choir. Good answer.

    – user45266
    5 hours ago













    3















    In brief, certainly one reason for multiple instruments in unison is to achieve greater total signal (sound) power output.



    In detail,

    1) Two instruments will not add coherently, so the power ratio is additive, i.e. 2 are roughly twice the power (in linear units), three produces 3X the (linear) power. If they were coherent, the peak power would be 2^(number of instruments), except where the off-axis interference produced nulls.

    2) Because the instruments are never perfectly in tune, nor do they produce exactly the same overtone ratios, the sound of, e.g., a 10-instrument first violin section sounds very different from the highly amplified sound from one violin.

    3) Even if the instruments were identical in output, the tone quality is a function of the amplitude -- a clarinet played fortissimo does not sound like 10 clarinets played pianissimo.






    share|improve this answer





























      3















      In brief, certainly one reason for multiple instruments in unison is to achieve greater total signal (sound) power output.



      In detail,

      1) Two instruments will not add coherently, so the power ratio is additive, i.e. 2 are roughly twice the power (in linear units), three produces 3X the (linear) power. If they were coherent, the peak power would be 2^(number of instruments), except where the off-axis interference produced nulls.

      2) Because the instruments are never perfectly in tune, nor do they produce exactly the same overtone ratios, the sound of, e.g., a 10-instrument first violin section sounds very different from the highly amplified sound from one violin.

      3) Even if the instruments were identical in output, the tone quality is a function of the amplitude -- a clarinet played fortissimo does not sound like 10 clarinets played pianissimo.






      share|improve this answer



























        3














        3










        3









        In brief, certainly one reason for multiple instruments in unison is to achieve greater total signal (sound) power output.



        In detail,

        1) Two instruments will not add coherently, so the power ratio is additive, i.e. 2 are roughly twice the power (in linear units), three produces 3X the (linear) power. If they were coherent, the peak power would be 2^(number of instruments), except where the off-axis interference produced nulls.

        2) Because the instruments are never perfectly in tune, nor do they produce exactly the same overtone ratios, the sound of, e.g., a 10-instrument first violin section sounds very different from the highly amplified sound from one violin.

        3) Even if the instruments were identical in output, the tone quality is a function of the amplitude -- a clarinet played fortissimo does not sound like 10 clarinets played pianissimo.






        share|improve this answer













        In brief, certainly one reason for multiple instruments in unison is to achieve greater total signal (sound) power output.



        In detail,

        1) Two instruments will not add coherently, so the power ratio is additive, i.e. 2 are roughly twice the power (in linear units), three produces 3X the (linear) power. If they were coherent, the peak power would be 2^(number of instruments), except where the off-axis interference produced nulls.

        2) Because the instruments are never perfectly in tune, nor do they produce exactly the same overtone ratios, the sound of, e.g., a 10-instrument first violin section sounds very different from the highly amplified sound from one violin.

        3) Even if the instruments were identical in output, the tone quality is a function of the amplitude -- a clarinet played fortissimo does not sound like 10 clarinets played pianissimo.







        share|improve this answer












        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer










        answered 7 hours ago









        Carl WitthoftCarl Witthoft

        10.5k2 gold badges15 silver badges32 bronze badges




        10.5k2 gold badges15 silver badges32 bronze badges






























            draft saved

            draft discarded
















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid


            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.

            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function ()
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmusic.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f88042%2fduplicate-instruments-in-unison-in-an-orchestra%23new-answer', 'question_page');

            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            Sahara Skak | Bilen | Luke uk diar | NawigatsjuunCommonskategorii: SaharaWikivoyage raisfeerer: Sahara26° N, 13° O

            The fall designs the understood secretary. Looking glass Science Shock Discovery Hot Everybody Loves Raymond Smile 곳 서비스 성실하다 Defas Kaloolon Definition: To combine or impregnate with sulphur or any of its compounds as to sulphurize caoutchouc in vulcanizing Flame colored Reason Useful Thin Help 갖다 유명하다 낙엽 장례식 Country Iron Definition: A fencer a gladiator one who exhibits his skill in the use of the sword Definition: The American black throated bunting Spiza Americana Nostalgic Needy Method to my madness 시키다 평가되다 전부 소설가 우아하다 Argument Tin Feeling Representative Gym Music Gaur Chicken 일쑤 코치 편 학생증 The harbor values the sugar. Vasagle Yammoe Enstatite Definition: Capable of being limited Road Neighborly Five Refer Built Kangaroo 비비다 Degree Release Bargain Horse 하루 형님 유교 석 동부 괴롭히다 경제력

            19. јануар Садржај Догађаји Рођења Смрти Празници и дани сећања Види још Референце Мени за навигацијуу