What are some good modern Brisker/Chakira based analysis sefarim by masechta?Is there a good visual companion to Tanach?Which books help one acquire a systematic understanding of Biblical Hebrew grammar?Online Gemoro ShiurimRecommendation for beginner's Aramaic language bookRecommendation for learning Hilchos Shabbos with familyWhat Hebrew must I know in order to read the Minchas Shai?Looking for the right daf yomi shiurFormal Logic and GemaraProblem with Likkutei MaharilWhy is Talmud Bavli studied more than Yerushalmi?
Why is my 401k manager recommending me to save more?
Emphasize numbers in tables
My players like to search everything. What do they find?
Why is the saxophone not common in classical repertoire?
I agreed to cancel a long-planned vacation (with travel costs) due to project deadlines, but now the timeline has all changed again
GFCI versus circuit breaker
What is the point of using the kunai?
Aligning arrays within arrays within another array
SQL Server Ignoring Instance name when using port number of different instance
What could a Medieval society do with excess animal blood?
How do I tell my girlfriend she's been buying me books by the wrong author for the last nine months?
How to idiomatically express the idea "if you can cheat without being caught, do it"
Sentences with no verb, but an ablative
How soon after takeoff can you recline your airplane seat?
Other homotopy invariants?
Does Dhp 256-257 condone judging others?
Is it OK to throw pebbles and stones in streams, waterfalls, ponds, etc.?
Trace in the category of propositional statements
What is the meaning of ゴト in the context of 鮎
Which high-degree derivatives play an essential role?
What verb goes with "coup"?
Is there a connection between representation theory and PDEs?
Why am I getting an electric shock from the water in my hot tub?
Tricky riddle from sister
What are some good modern Brisker/Chakira based analysis sefarim by masechta?
Is there a good visual companion to Tanach?Which books help one acquire a systematic understanding of Biblical Hebrew grammar?Online Gemoro ShiurimRecommendation for beginner's Aramaic language bookRecommendation for learning Hilchos Shabbos with familyWhat Hebrew must I know in order to read the Minchas Shai?Looking for the right daf yomi shiurFormal Logic and GemaraProblem with Likkutei MaharilWhy is Talmud Bavli studied more than Yerushalmi?
I'm a big fan of the Brisker/Chakira approach to gemara b'iyun and looking for a sefer that I can use to learn either alone or with a chavrusa.
I'm looking for something in Hebrew, and (a) by masechta, and (b) something more modern than the Briskers themselves.
talmud-gemara jewish-books brisk
asked 19 hours ago
MJGMJG
243 bronze badges
New contributor
MJG is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
add a comment |
I'm a big fan of the Brisker/Chakira approach to gemara b'iyun and looking for a sefer that I can use to learn either alone or with a chavrusa.
I'm looking for something in Hebrew, and (a) by masechta, and (b) something more modern than the Briskers themselves.
talmud-gemara jewish-books brisk
asked 19 hours ago
MJGMJG
243 bronze badges
New contributor
MJG is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
Welcome to MiYodeya MJG and thanks for this first question. Can I recommend you take the tour to get a sense of how the site works? Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
18 hours ago
1
Have you read any works by R Aharon Lichtenstein
– Double AA♦
15 hours ago
1
@DoubleAA I have, they're good, but I found them a little longwinded and quite hard to follow. Also not so classically 'brisk' in the straight chakira sense. But I haven't seen all the volumes.
– MJG
14 hours ago
If you found them hard to follow I don't know how you can understand R Chaim. Long-winded is more like explicit, unlike most classic briskers who are obfuscatingly terse. I also don't know what you mean by the striaght chakira sense. Unless indeed you are looking for a more simplified presentation of sugyot.
– Double AA♦
14 hours ago
1
MJG why so many rollbacks? People with a lot of experience are trying to help
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
add a comment |
I'm a big fan of the Brisker/Chakira approach to gemara b'iyun and looking for a sefer that I can use to learn either alone or with a chavrusa.
I'm looking for something in Hebrew, and (a) by masechta, and (b) something more modern than the Briskers themselves.
talmud-gemara jewish-books brisk
asked 19 hours ago
MJGMJG
243 bronze badges
New contributor
MJG is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
I'm a big fan of the Brisker/Chakira approach to gemara b'iyun and looking for a sefer that I can use to learn either alone or with a chavrusa.
I'm looking for something in Hebrew, and (a) by masechta, and (b) something more modern than the Briskers themselves.
talmud-gemara jewish-books brisk
talmud-gemara jewish-books brisk
asked 19 hours ago
MJGMJG
243 bronze badges
New contributor
MJG is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
asked 19 hours ago
MJGMJG
243 bronze badges
New contributor
MJG is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
edited 7 hours ago
MJG
asked 19 hours ago
MJGMJG
243 bronze badges
New contributor
MJG is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
asked 19 hours ago
MJGMJG
243 bronze badges
asked 19 hours ago
MJGMJG
243 bronze badges
243 bronze badges
New contributor
MJG is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
New contributor
MJG is a new contributor to this site. Take care in asking for clarification, commenting, and answering.
Check out our Code of Conduct.
Welcome to MiYodeya MJG and thanks for this first question. Can I recommend you take the tour to get a sense of how the site works? Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
18 hours ago
1
Have you read any works by R Aharon Lichtenstein
– Double AA♦
15 hours ago
1
@DoubleAA I have, they're good, but I found them a little longwinded and quite hard to follow. Also not so classically 'brisk' in the straight chakira sense. But I haven't seen all the volumes.
– MJG
14 hours ago
If you found them hard to follow I don't know how you can understand R Chaim. Long-winded is more like explicit, unlike most classic briskers who are obfuscatingly terse. I also don't know what you mean by the striaght chakira sense. Unless indeed you are looking for a more simplified presentation of sugyot.
– Double AA♦
14 hours ago
1
MJG why so many rollbacks? People with a lot of experience are trying to help
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
add a comment |
Welcome to MiYodeya MJG and thanks for this first question. Can I recommend you take the tour to get a sense of how the site works? Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
18 hours ago
1
Have you read any works by R Aharon Lichtenstein
– Double AA♦
15 hours ago
1
@DoubleAA I have, they're good, but I found them a little longwinded and quite hard to follow. Also not so classically 'brisk' in the straight chakira sense. But I haven't seen all the volumes.
– MJG
14 hours ago
If you found them hard to follow I don't know how you can understand R Chaim. Long-winded is more like explicit, unlike most classic briskers who are obfuscatingly terse. I also don't know what you mean by the striaght chakira sense. Unless indeed you are looking for a more simplified presentation of sugyot.
– Double AA♦
14 hours ago
1
MJG why so many rollbacks? People with a lot of experience are trying to help
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
Welcome to MiYodeya MJG and thanks for this first question. Can I recommend you take the tour to get a sense of how the site works? Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
18 hours ago
Welcome to MiYodeya MJG and thanks for this first question. Can I recommend you take the tour to get a sense of how the site works? Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
18 hours ago
1
1
Have you read any works by R Aharon Lichtenstein
– Double AA♦
15 hours ago
Have you read any works by R Aharon Lichtenstein
– Double AA♦
15 hours ago
1
1
@DoubleAA I have, they're good, but I found them a little longwinded and quite hard to follow. Also not so classically 'brisk' in the straight chakira sense. But I haven't seen all the volumes.
– MJG
14 hours ago
@DoubleAA I have, they're good, but I found them a little longwinded and quite hard to follow. Also not so classically 'brisk' in the straight chakira sense. But I haven't seen all the volumes.
– MJG
14 hours ago
If you found them hard to follow I don't know how you can understand R Chaim. Long-winded is more like explicit, unlike most classic briskers who are obfuscatingly terse. I also don't know what you mean by the striaght chakira sense. Unless indeed you are looking for a more simplified presentation of sugyot.
– Double AA♦
14 hours ago
If you found them hard to follow I don't know how you can understand R Chaim. Long-winded is more like explicit, unlike most classic briskers who are obfuscatingly terse. I also don't know what you mean by the striaght chakira sense. Unless indeed you are looking for a more simplified presentation of sugyot.
– Double AA♦
14 hours ago
1
1
MJG why so many rollbacks? People with a lot of experience are trying to help
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
MJG why so many rollbacks? People with a lot of experience are trying to help
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
Here are some: Kovetz Shiurim (R. Elchanan Wasserman), Chiddushei R. Reuven (Grozovsky), Chiddushei R. Shlomo (Heiman), Shiurei R. Shmuel (Rozovsky), Shiurei R. Dovid (Povarsky), Shiurei Avi Ezri (R. Schach), Kehillos Yaakov (R. Y. Y. Kanievsky), Reshimos Shiurim (R. Y. D. Soloveitchik), Chiddushei R. Yechiel Michel (Feinstein), Shiurei R. Meshulam Dovid (Soloveitchik), Shiurei Iyun Hatalmud (R. Aba Berman), and most of the seforim by roshei yeshiva of the last century. Another good recent work on many masechtos is Birkas Avraham (R. Avraham Erlenger). There are also seforim which collect many of these chiddushim, such as Ateres Shmuel and Ohel Torah.
answered 6 hours ago
wfbwfb
10.8k27 silver badges61 bronze badges
Excellent answer, many thanks. I will check these out.
– MJG
6 hours ago
2
Excellent list,however, some of those works are quite difficult reads
– sam
6 hours ago
1
@sam I didn't even include Kuntres HaBiurim
– wfb
2 hours ago
double points for anybody who links these in (I assume)
– Dr. Shmuel
47 mins ago
add a comment |
I would suggest Shiurei HaRav (Soloveitcik) ,and Hararei Kedem. They both include the Brisker style analysis of chakirah. They aren't too lengthy and Hararei Kedem is very easy to follow.
answered 11 hours ago
samsam
27.8k1 gold badge54 silver badges105 bronze badges
Was going to be my suggestion...
– רבות מחשבות
11 hours ago
Harerei Kedem is not arranged by masechet
– Joel K
11 hours ago
1
That is why I mentioned both, and Hararei Kedem on shabbas is mostly on sugyos on Masheches shabbas ,so basically on shabbas,the Moadim also go on their topic mashechta on most topics .
– sam
11 hours ago
I'm a big fan of Hararei Kedem. Are you referring to Shiurei HaGrid? I've actually never taken a look at that - how similar is it to Hararei Kedem?
– MJG
7 hours ago
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Here are some: Kovetz Shiurim (R. Elchanan Wasserman), Chiddushei R. Reuven (Grozovsky), Chiddushei R. Shlomo (Heiman), Shiurei R. Shmuel (Rozovsky), Shiurei R. Dovid (Povarsky), Shiurei Avi Ezri (R. Schach), Kehillos Yaakov (R. Y. Y. Kanievsky), Reshimos Shiurim (R. Y. D. Soloveitchik), Chiddushei R. Yechiel Michel (Feinstein), Shiurei R. Meshulam Dovid (Soloveitchik), Shiurei Iyun Hatalmud (R. Aba Berman), and most of the seforim by roshei yeshiva of the last century. Another good recent work on many masechtos is Birkas Avraham (R. Avraham Erlenger). There are also seforim which collect many of these chiddushim, such as Ateres Shmuel and Ohel Torah.
answered 6 hours ago
wfbwfb
10.8k27 silver badges61 bronze badges
Excellent answer, many thanks. I will check these out.
– MJG
6 hours ago
2
Excellent list,however, some of those works are quite difficult reads
– sam
6 hours ago
1
@sam I didn't even include Kuntres HaBiurim
– wfb
2 hours ago
double points for anybody who links these in (I assume)
– Dr. Shmuel
47 mins ago
add a comment |
Here are some: Kovetz Shiurim (R. Elchanan Wasserman), Chiddushei R. Reuven (Grozovsky), Chiddushei R. Shlomo (Heiman), Shiurei R. Shmuel (Rozovsky), Shiurei R. Dovid (Povarsky), Shiurei Avi Ezri (R. Schach), Kehillos Yaakov (R. Y. Y. Kanievsky), Reshimos Shiurim (R. Y. D. Soloveitchik), Chiddushei R. Yechiel Michel (Feinstein), Shiurei R. Meshulam Dovid (Soloveitchik), Shiurei Iyun Hatalmud (R. Aba Berman), and most of the seforim by roshei yeshiva of the last century. Another good recent work on many masechtos is Birkas Avraham (R. Avraham Erlenger). There are also seforim which collect many of these chiddushim, such as Ateres Shmuel and Ohel Torah.
answered 6 hours ago
wfbwfb
10.8k27 silver badges61 bronze badges
Excellent answer, many thanks. I will check these out.
– MJG
6 hours ago
2
Excellent list,however, some of those works are quite difficult reads
– sam
6 hours ago
1
@sam I didn't even include Kuntres HaBiurim
– wfb
2 hours ago
double points for anybody who links these in (I assume)
– Dr. Shmuel
47 mins ago
add a comment |
Here are some: Kovetz Shiurim (R. Elchanan Wasserman), Chiddushei R. Reuven (Grozovsky), Chiddushei R. Shlomo (Heiman), Shiurei R. Shmuel (Rozovsky), Shiurei R. Dovid (Povarsky), Shiurei Avi Ezri (R. Schach), Kehillos Yaakov (R. Y. Y. Kanievsky), Reshimos Shiurim (R. Y. D. Soloveitchik), Chiddushei R. Yechiel Michel (Feinstein), Shiurei R. Meshulam Dovid (Soloveitchik), Shiurei Iyun Hatalmud (R. Aba Berman), and most of the seforim by roshei yeshiva of the last century. Another good recent work on many masechtos is Birkas Avraham (R. Avraham Erlenger). There are also seforim which collect many of these chiddushim, such as Ateres Shmuel and Ohel Torah.
answered 6 hours ago
wfbwfb
10.8k27 silver badges61 bronze badges
Here are some: Kovetz Shiurim (R. Elchanan Wasserman), Chiddushei R. Reuven (Grozovsky), Chiddushei R. Shlomo (Heiman), Shiurei R. Shmuel (Rozovsky), Shiurei R. Dovid (Povarsky), Shiurei Avi Ezri (R. Schach), Kehillos Yaakov (R. Y. Y. Kanievsky), Reshimos Shiurim (R. Y. D. Soloveitchik), Chiddushei R. Yechiel Michel (Feinstein), Shiurei R. Meshulam Dovid (Soloveitchik), Shiurei Iyun Hatalmud (R. Aba Berman), and most of the seforim by roshei yeshiva of the last century. Another good recent work on many masechtos is Birkas Avraham (R. Avraham Erlenger). There are also seforim which collect many of these chiddushim, such as Ateres Shmuel and Ohel Torah.
answered 6 hours ago
wfbwfb
10.8k27 silver badges61 bronze badges
edited 2 hours ago
answered 6 hours ago
wfbwfb
10.8k27 silver badges61 bronze badges
answered 6 hours ago
wfbwfb
10.8k27 silver badges61 bronze badges
answered 6 hours ago
wfbwfb
10.8k27 silver badges61 bronze badges
10.8k27 silver badges61 bronze badges
Excellent answer, many thanks. I will check these out.
– MJG
6 hours ago
2
Excellent list,however, some of those works are quite difficult reads
– sam
6 hours ago
1
@sam I didn't even include Kuntres HaBiurim
– wfb
2 hours ago
double points for anybody who links these in (I assume)
– Dr. Shmuel
47 mins ago
add a comment |
Excellent answer, many thanks. I will check these out.
– MJG
6 hours ago
2
Excellent list,however, some of those works are quite difficult reads
– sam
6 hours ago
1
@sam I didn't even include Kuntres HaBiurim
– wfb
2 hours ago
double points for anybody who links these in (I assume)
– Dr. Shmuel
47 mins ago
Excellent answer, many thanks. I will check these out.
– MJG
6 hours ago
Excellent answer, many thanks. I will check these out.
– MJG
6 hours ago
2
2
Excellent list,however, some of those works are quite difficult reads
– sam
6 hours ago
Excellent list,however, some of those works are quite difficult reads
– sam
6 hours ago
1
1
@sam I didn't even include Kuntres HaBiurim
– wfb
2 hours ago
@sam I didn't even include Kuntres HaBiurim
– wfb
2 hours ago
double points for anybody who links these in (I assume)
– Dr. Shmuel
47 mins ago
double points for anybody who links these in (I assume)
– Dr. Shmuel
47 mins ago
add a comment |
I would suggest Shiurei HaRav (Soloveitcik) ,and Hararei Kedem. They both include the Brisker style analysis of chakirah. They aren't too lengthy and Hararei Kedem is very easy to follow.
answered 11 hours ago
samsam
27.8k1 gold badge54 silver badges105 bronze badges
Was going to be my suggestion...
– רבות מחשבות
11 hours ago
Harerei Kedem is not arranged by masechet
– Joel K
11 hours ago
1
That is why I mentioned both, and Hararei Kedem on shabbas is mostly on sugyos on Masheches shabbas ,so basically on shabbas,the Moadim also go on their topic mashechta on most topics .
– sam
11 hours ago
I'm a big fan of Hararei Kedem. Are you referring to Shiurei HaGrid? I've actually never taken a look at that - how similar is it to Hararei Kedem?
– MJG
7 hours ago
add a comment |
I would suggest Shiurei HaRav (Soloveitcik) ,and Hararei Kedem. They both include the Brisker style analysis of chakirah. They aren't too lengthy and Hararei Kedem is very easy to follow.
answered 11 hours ago
samsam
27.8k1 gold badge54 silver badges105 bronze badges
Was going to be my suggestion...
– רבות מחשבות
11 hours ago
Harerei Kedem is not arranged by masechet
– Joel K
11 hours ago
1
That is why I mentioned both, and Hararei Kedem on shabbas is mostly on sugyos on Masheches shabbas ,so basically on shabbas,the Moadim also go on their topic mashechta on most topics .
– sam
11 hours ago
I'm a big fan of Hararei Kedem. Are you referring to Shiurei HaGrid? I've actually never taken a look at that - how similar is it to Hararei Kedem?
– MJG
7 hours ago
add a comment |
I would suggest Shiurei HaRav (Soloveitcik) ,and Hararei Kedem. They both include the Brisker style analysis of chakirah. They aren't too lengthy and Hararei Kedem is very easy to follow.
answered 11 hours ago
samsam
27.8k1 gold badge54 silver badges105 bronze badges
I would suggest Shiurei HaRav (Soloveitcik) ,and Hararei Kedem. They both include the Brisker style analysis of chakirah. They aren't too lengthy and Hararei Kedem is very easy to follow.
answered 11 hours ago
samsam
27.8k1 gold badge54 silver badges105 bronze badges
answered 11 hours ago
samsam
27.8k1 gold badge54 silver badges105 bronze badges
answered 11 hours ago
samsam
27.8k1 gold badge54 silver badges105 bronze badges
answered 11 hours ago
samsam
27.8k1 gold badge54 silver badges105 bronze badges
27.8k1 gold badge54 silver badges105 bronze badges
Was going to be my suggestion...
– רבות מחשבות
11 hours ago
Harerei Kedem is not arranged by masechet
– Joel K
11 hours ago
1
That is why I mentioned both, and Hararei Kedem on shabbas is mostly on sugyos on Masheches shabbas ,so basically on shabbas,the Moadim also go on their topic mashechta on most topics .
– sam
11 hours ago
I'm a big fan of Hararei Kedem. Are you referring to Shiurei HaGrid? I've actually never taken a look at that - how similar is it to Hararei Kedem?
– MJG
7 hours ago
add a comment |
Was going to be my suggestion...
– רבות מחשבות
11 hours ago
Harerei Kedem is not arranged by masechet
– Joel K
11 hours ago
1
That is why I mentioned both, and Hararei Kedem on shabbas is mostly on sugyos on Masheches shabbas ,so basically on shabbas,the Moadim also go on their topic mashechta on most topics .
– sam
11 hours ago
I'm a big fan of Hararei Kedem. Are you referring to Shiurei HaGrid? I've actually never taken a look at that - how similar is it to Hararei Kedem?
– MJG
7 hours ago
Was going to be my suggestion...
– רבות מחשבות
11 hours ago
Was going to be my suggestion...
– רבות מחשבות
11 hours ago
Harerei Kedem is not arranged by masechet
– Joel K
11 hours ago
Harerei Kedem is not arranged by masechet
– Joel K
11 hours ago
1
1
That is why I mentioned both, and Hararei Kedem on shabbas is mostly on sugyos on Masheches shabbas ,so basically on shabbas,the Moadim also go on their topic mashechta on most topics .
– sam
11 hours ago
That is why I mentioned both, and Hararei Kedem on shabbas is mostly on sugyos on Masheches shabbas ,so basically on shabbas,the Moadim also go on their topic mashechta on most topics .
– sam
11 hours ago
I'm a big fan of Hararei Kedem. Are you referring to Shiurei HaGrid? I've actually never taken a look at that - how similar is it to Hararei Kedem?
– MJG
7 hours ago
I'm a big fan of Hararei Kedem. Are you referring to Shiurei HaGrid? I've actually never taken a look at that - how similar is it to Hararei Kedem?
– MJG
7 hours ago
add a comment |
Welcome to MiYodeya MJG and thanks for this first question. Can I recommend you take the tour to get a sense of how the site works? Great to have you learn with us!
– mbloch
18 hours ago
1
Have you read any works by R Aharon Lichtenstein
– Double AA♦
15 hours ago
1
@DoubleAA I have, they're good, but I found them a little longwinded and quite hard to follow. Also not so classically 'brisk' in the straight chakira sense. But I haven't seen all the volumes.
– MJG
14 hours ago
If you found them hard to follow I don't know how you can understand R Chaim. Long-winded is more like explicit, unlike most classic briskers who are obfuscatingly terse. I also don't know what you mean by the striaght chakira sense. Unless indeed you are looking for a more simplified presentation of sugyot.
– Double AA♦
14 hours ago
1
MJG why so many rollbacks? People with a lot of experience are trying to help
– Double AA♦
7 hours ago